Tuesday, September 17, 2013

Sexism and my friend Dolores

 After Tony Abbott won the election I had a foolhardy dream. I actually believed for a minute that people might wait and see if all their dire predictions would come true. Sadly, I was wrong. The name-calling, the spite, the anger (and other signs of being a sore loser) were more prevalent than ever. Already the articles have started about all the bad things our new PM (who at the time of typing this hasn't even been sworn in as PM yet) has done. Disgusting groups like  "Tony Abbott is the worst PM in history" have sprouted up and at least 50 friends of mine on my FB page have joined it. I'm glad that spirit of "giving a person a fair go" is still alive and well in 21st Century Australia. Oh yes, I even got defriended by one person for daring to post a pro-Abbott video on my page (in response to the countless anti-Abbott articles, memes and such filling up my page which they posted).
 But you know what? We live in a country where all of that is possible without fear of death. I would rather people be engaged with political debate in this country then to sit passively by and say "I hate them all". I'll take a person who weighs up the pros and cons and reaches a conclusion that is different to my own anyday.
 I am proud to call some of those people my friends. Fellow musicians who I admire a lot but who think different politically to me. At least they care about this country. One of those is my friend Dolores [not their real name]. We've done shows together and she has always been a good friend to me. She is an outstanding teacher, a wonderful mum and wife and has been a great support to me as I do my degree. But her views on politics could not be more different than my own. On election day I actually messaged her on FB and apologised that we seemed to only talk when disagreeing on politics. She laughed and said it didn't matter- and she reminded me that she married a Liberal voter. The fact she is still my friend sometimes amazes me given some of the exchanges we have had in the past.
 Today was no different. The feminists have been having a field day since Mr. Abbott announced his cabinet with ONLY ONE WOMAN!!!! (du-du-DUUUUH!!!) Poor Corinne Grant must have steam coming off her keyboard writing so furiously to get a blog up on The Hoopla! How dare he!! Nice way to set women's rights back 50 years!! Oh the outrage, the anger, the venom!! 
 Dolores jumped in with a pithy status and, despite my better judgement, I went wading in right after her. Do I seriously need another target on my back??
 Of course, any attempt to defend the decision would be immediately leaped upon and branded as sexist (especially when coming from a man) and it didn't take long. So before I get the tirades of abuse, let me try and point out my views on the this.
 Let's play a hypothetical-
 You have to fill a position. You have two possibilities to fill that vacancy. One person is experienced and has a solid background in the job. They also are qualified and have proven themselves as a team player. The other person is nowhere near as qualified, has little experience and has yet to prove themselves. Which one do you go for? Now if this were a rather lowly position you may be tempted to make a judgement call and decide that a person has to start somewhere and if they screw up then no harm, no foul. But this is a senior position with a LOT riding on it. In this instance, I think a good boss will go with the first person. To me, that makes sound, business sense. It matters not what their age, gender, religion or race is. You picked the best person for the job.
 That is the choice the PM-elect has had to make. I note that Mr. Abbott is also nominating Bronwyn Bishop as speaker of the House of Reps (which would make the most powerful position in the house being filled by a woman- something a lot of the people are forgetting). By the way, I imagine he put the same criteria on filling THAT position as he did in filling in the cabinet positions. 
 When I looked through the ministry I saw a lot of experience both as opposition spokesperson and from outside Parliament. What I saw was a team capable of bringing solid government to this country and representing our country well. 
 "But what about the WOMEN"??? Dolores cried. She rightly pointed out that women are just as capable of doing these jobs as men and that they make up 50% of the population. I don't disagree with her on that at all. Sadly, the pool of talent that our new PM had to choose from wasn't very representative of that. I suppose we can argue about the Liberals not blooding enough female talent and you might have a point, but the simple fact is that if not enough women want to run as a candidate for the party then it is very hard for them to be elected and then put into cabinet. Is that the PM-elects' fault? As Mr. Abbott pointed out yesterday there several women knocking on cabinet's door. Good. Come time for a reshuffle, one or two of them may just enter into that room having had more experience under their belt.
 I am all for women getting the same opportunities as men- they are as capable (and in some cases, more capable) of doing the job as their male counterparts if they are the right person for the job!! It's not sexism, it's actually good business sense- the right person for the right job.
I still greatly respect Dolores and will continue to do so. She's awesome. 

No comments:

Post a Comment